Contact Us
Firm Overview
Why Legend Is Different
Client Types
Professional Biographies
Frequently & Rarely Asked Questions
Risk Spectrum
Investment Strategies
Second Opinion
Global Investment Pulse
Event Calendar
Press Center
Legend News
Clients Only
Career Opportunities
Directions
Newsletter Sign-up
Site Search
Site Map
Home
Tell A Friend About This Website
 
 
 
Informational Booklets   
Phone: (412) 635-9210
  (888) 236-5960
Connect With Legend:
Subscribe to me on YouTube

Is Your 401(k) Plan A Failure?

The decline of the stock market over the last 2½ years, and the devastating bankruptcies of such companies as Enron and WorldCom, have prompted critics to call 401(k) plans a failure. Some have even called the two-decade old concept a scam and say employers need to return to the traditional pension plan to ensure that workers will have enough funds for retirement. 401(k) supporters counter that the problem is not with the plans themselves so much as the way participants use them.

Whatever the pros and cons of the debate, 401(k) plans are here to stay, and plan participants can do more to make their 401(k) an effective way to build a comfortable nest egg. The following are some of the criticisms of 401(k)s and what participants can do to minimize potential drawbacks.

Participation. Critics contend that all eligible workers benefit from a traditional pension plan, whereas 401(k) participation is voluntary. According to the Profit-Sharing/401(k) Council of America, roughly 75 to 80 percent of eligible workers participate in 401(k) plans, with participation rates even lower among younger workers and low-income workers.

Proponents note that more companies are providing automatic enrollments in 401(k) plans, which requires workers to opt out of participation. In these plans, participation rates are around 95 percent, according to the benefits consulting firm of Hewitt Associates.

Proponents also point out that if it weren’t for 401(k) plans, many workers wouldn’t have any type of retirement plan because 90 percent of 401(k) plans are offered by small companies who typically wouldn’t offer a traditional defined-benefit plan.

Failure to contribute as much as possible. The average 401(k) participant contributes less than seven percent of pre-tax salary, according to the Employee Benefit Research Institute. Financial advisors encourage workers to contribute at least ten percent or more of pre-tax salary.

Poor investment decisions. In a traditional pension plan, the company makes the investment decisions. In a 401(k) plan, all workers must be their own investment manager—a task many are not up to. Workers typically don’t diversify well, either loading up on company stock or investing too much in lower-returning fixed-income options. Proponents concede that the average 401(k) plan offers too few investment options for workers, but workers compound the limited choice by choosing only two to three funds, and often similar or overlapping funds at that. Fortunately, workers can seek professional independent investment advice to help them make smart investment choices.

Vulnerability to market fluctuations. A traditional defined-benefit pension plan promises that you will receive your pension payments at retirement, typically based on your highest salary and years of service, regardless of the ups and downs of the market and the economy. If the company’s plan can’t meet its obligations, the federal government will step in, though higher-paid workers may not receive all the benefits they are entitled to. 401(k) plans don’t have any guaranteed payments.

Proponents argue that workers can protect themselves better against market volatility through greater savings and long-term diversification, instead of trying to hit a home run as many workers attempted in the 1990s.

Proponents also point out that pension payouts during retirement typically are not adjusted for inflation—your pension will lose purchasing power over time. A well-invested 401(k) can keep up with inflation so you don’t lose ground.

Cashing out 401(k) plans. Another criticism of 401(k) plans is that when workers change jobs—which they do every four to five years on average—many cash out what they’ve saved and spend it. This is particularly true among younger workers. The money not only can no longer grow tax deferred, but the withdrawal faces income taxes and usually a ten-percent early withdrawal penalty.

Proponents agree that workers need to roll over their accounts into an individual retirement account or another employer’s retirement plan. But they also point out that this portability of 401(k) plans is one of the pluses. The payout from a pension plan can be excellent if you stay at the same company for 30 years, but who does that anymore? If you change jobs every four to five years, you may not even qualify for the pension, or payments will remain small because you don’t have the years of service.

Traditional pension plans and 401(k)s each will continue to have their pros and cons. The important point is that workers must better educate themselves about their plan options so they can make smart choices, whichever type of plan they use.

For Further information on 401(k) plans contact Louis P. Stanasolovich, CFP™, CEO and President at (412) 635-9210 Extension 21.



INDEX
  • 6 Ways To Close The Retirement Gap
  • IRS Closes Valuation Loopholes
  • Passing Down IRA Assets? Clue In Family Members
  • This Type Of Trust Is A Failure
  • Grandparents Can Become Big Spenders For Their Offspring
  • Time Your Social Security Benefits For Top Results
  • Watch Out For These 7 Retirement Ups And Downs
  • Why Would Anyone Take Their RMDs Sooner?
  • 10 Frequent Retirement Mistakes You Should Avoid
  • Tax Rewards For Year-End Generosity
  • Meeting With The Family For Elder Care Planning
  • 20 Questions On Required Minimum Distributions
  • Tie The Knot For Retirement With A Spousal IRA
  • Four Retirement Planning Rules Of Thumb To Bend
  • When Will New College Grads Be Able To Retire?
  • Last Chance To File-And-Suspend Retiree Benefits
  • You Know You're Getting Old When You Get RMD Notice
  • 10 Steps To Take On The Path To Early Retirement
  • How To REALLY Get Ready For Your Retirement Years
  • Can You Skip Over The Special Tax For Generation-Skipping?
  • What Do You Think Your Life Will Be Like In Retirement?
  • Raiding A Roth Early? No Woes
  • Live Long And Prosper: Roll Out A Stretch IRA
  • Did The Devil Make You Do It? 8 Retirement Miscues
  • Ponder These 4 Reasons For Roth IRA Conversions
  • 10 Ways To Skirt A Penalty Tax On Plan Payouts
  • Why Give Securities To Charity Instead Of Cash?
  • Will You Have To Lower Your Sights In Retirement?
  • What Will $2 Million Get You In Your Retirement?
  • Figuring Out How Much You Need In Retirement
  • Should You Borrow Against A Life Insurance Policy?
  • How Will Your Retirement Distributions Be Taxed?
  • Five Ways To Plan Smarter And For The Long Haul
  • 5 Withdrawal Strategies For Retirement Savings
  • Five Ways To Plan Smarter And For The Long Haul
  • Generation X Members Have Retirement Work Cut Out For Them
  • Booted From A 401(k)? Don't Despair
  • It's Tough To Decide If You Should Retire Early
  • Saving For Retirement At All Ages
  • Which Type Of IRA Do You Prefer?
  • Owning REIT Shares Can Help Minimize Risk
  • Roundup Of New Estate Tax Changes
  • Here Are A Dozen Part-Time Jobs For Older Americans
  • Two More Important Choices For Retirement Living
  • Will Your Retirement Assets Last?
  • The Benefits Of Working With An Advisor
  • Setting Up A Roth IRA Through The ''Back Door''
  • Eight Of The Best Tax Strategies To Use In 2012
  • 10 ''Baby Steps'' To Take If You Are Newly Widowed
  • A Case Study: Retirement Planning In Your Fifties
  • Factors In Researching An Assisted Living Facility
  • New Wrinkle In Pre-59 1/2 IRA Withdrawals
  • A Case Study: Giving Wealth Away
  • Social Security's Online Benefits Estimating Tool
  • Estate Tax Exemptions Survive Longer
  • Will New Estate Tax Rules Lull You Into Inaction?
  • The Fine Art Of Planning For Collectibles
  • Five Tips To Manage Your 401(k) Wisely
  • A Comprehensive Way To Save For Your Retirement
  • Key Factors In Conducting Your 401(k) Vendor Search
  • Assessing The Damage To Pre-Retiree Financial Plans
  • Where Have Vacation-Home Prices Dropped The Most?
  • Giving Up Control Of Your Finances
  • Estate Tax Purgatory: How To Extricate Yourself
  • Cheap Thrills: 10 Ways To Enjoy Life In A Recession
  • Adjusting To The New Reality About Your Retirement
  • What Should You Spend First During Retirement?
  • Retirement Planning Does Not Stop When You Retire
  • Part-Time Job Hunting Tips for Retirees
  • Weighing The Benefits Of Investing In A Roth 401(k)
  • Keep A Leash On Part Of Your Estate
  • Pre-Retirees, Retirees Switch To Roth IRA
  • The Obama Bank Plan And The Risks It Poses
  • New Law Suspends RMDs For Just One Year
  • The Importance Of Year-Round Tax Planning
  • Charitable Giving Rules Changed By Pension Act
  • Market Gyrations Raise Questions For Pre-Retirees
  • Passing More Than Money To Your Heirs
  • How Many Years Should You Retain Your Tax Records?
  • Key Questions For Those Nearing Retirement
  • Retirement Planning Does Not Stop When You Retire
  • Dealing With Market Risk Right After Retirement
  • Nine Estate Planning Mistakes To Avoid
  • Family Foundation Lets You Do Good For Others And Yourself
  • Treating Your Retirement As A Liability
  • Beware Of Social Security Identity Theft
  • Regulatory Guidelines Update
  • Understanding the Importance of a Fiduciary Standard
  • Don't Forget About Roth 401(k)
  • Free Credit Reports Available Online
  • Energy Systems Scale and Timeline
  • The Oil Patch Profit Squeeze
  • Timber As A Liquid Investment
  • Timber Facts
  • Ethanol: Salvation or Panacea?
  • Timber Facts
  • Emerging Market Food Consumption Growth Equals Rising Prices
  • Bank Loan Funds - A Primer
  • A Primer On Managed Futures
  • REITS: A Very Good Portfolio Diversifier, But Should You Invest In Them?
  • Does Investing Internationally Still Diversify Your Portfolio?
  • Another Way To View The Current Valuation Of REIT Sector
  • Understanding Risk-Preparing For The Unseen
  • A Critical View Of The Consumer Price Index
  • What Is Shorting Expense?
  • How Dangerous Is A Dollar Crash?
  • How Volatile Can The Stock Market Be?
  • GMO 7-Year Asset Class Return Forecast Is Bleak
  • Too Many ''Phish'' In The Sea
  • The Case For Industrial Metals
  • Identity Theft In The New Year
  • Ways To Improve The Score
  • Know The Score
  • Total Credit Market Debt (All Sectors) As % Of U.S. GDP
  • To Reinvest Or Not To Reinvest
  • Why Not Alternative Fixed Income Investments?
  • Just How Expensive Is The Market?
  • Beware of Brokerage Firms' Misconduct
  • Identity Theft : Correct Those Credit Reporting Errors
  • Risk-Controlled Investing
  • Q & A With Robert Arnott
  • Identity Theft : Applying For Credit? Better Check Your Credit Report First
  • Indentity Theft: Help Is On Its Way
  • Identity Theft: Everyday Prevention
  • Indentity Theft: Tips to Protect Yourself
  • Identity Theft : Tips to Protect Yourself
  • Identity Theft: A Note About Social Security Numbers
  • Identity Theft: Which Documents Should You Shred or Store?
  • Identity Theft : Don't Fall For That E-Mail!
  • Identity Theft : One More Reason To Protect Your Credit
  • What Do Rising Interest Rates Mean For Money Market Yields?
  • Exit Gracefully: How Business Owners Should Plan For A Comfortable Retirement
  • Section 529 Plans Are Popular But Not The Only Way To Go
  • The Importance Of Commodities In A Portfolio
  • A Tale Of Two Hedges
  • Bank Loan Funds: A Great Fixed Income Investment As Interest Rates Rise
  • REITs: A Great Diversification Investment
  • What Is Risk?
  • How To Find A Great Financial Advisor?
  • Is It Time To Find A New Financial Advisor?
  • Year-End Tax Planning Can Help Generate High Return On Investment
  • 4 Steps To A More Secure Investment Portfolio For Your Retirement
  • Traditional Investing May Decrease Your Retirement Lifestyle
  • Is Your 401(k) Plan A Failure?
  • Understanding Deflation
  • Tax Issues To Consider When Buying A Long-Term-Care Policy
  • Evaluating The Quality Of A Company's Earnings
  • Investing In Times Of Uncertainty And Risk: The Importance Of Diversification
  • Yesterday's Great Companies
  • A Retirement Plan Primer After The 2001 Tax Act
  • Beware Of Common Home Repair Scams
  • Estate Taxes To Be Reduced Then Repealed In 2010
  • Faulty IRA Conversions Can Lead To Tax Penalties
  • Many Individuals Pay Private Mortgage Insurance Beyond When It Is Necessary
  • Rethinking Estate Planning
  • Early Retirement Incentives For Tenured Faculty Waives Fica Tax Payment
  • Retirement Plan Contribution Limit Changes
  • Shopping For A Bank Account That Pays The Highest Possible Rate Of Interest
  • Your Medical File Report May Need A Check-Up
  • Do It Yourself Tax Preparers Watch Out: Tax Answers From IRS Centers Oftentimes Are Incorrect And/Or Insufficient
  • Five Tips For Preventing Thefts From Your Checking Account
  • Home Office Deductions: Hoops To Jump Through
  • Income Tax Effect On Single And Married Taxpayers
  • Income Tax Planning For Investments
  • Property Tax Challenges Should Not Be Overlooked
  • The IRS Will Follow Your Wealth To The Ends Of The Earth
  • Under New Law Taking Social Security at 65 Makes Sense for Most
  • When Do You Need Life Insurance
  • Year-End Tax Defferal Planning



  • ©2017 Legend Financial Advisors, Inc.®. All rights reserved.